Stop the virtual presses: I agree with Mel Kiper!

Mel Kiper called the Colts “one of the worst teams in the NFL without Peyton Manning” and the esteemed Trent Dilfer (no Manning he) agreed. Let’s see if we agree.

QB Peyton Manning (if re-signed) A+ Option is Curtis Painter F

RB Joseph Addai (if re-signed) C+ Option is Donald Brown D-

FL Pierre Garcon C+

SE Reggie Wayne A

3rd WR Austin Collie A (if healthy)

TE Dallas Clark A

H-B Brody Eldridge B-

RT Ryan Diem C- declining

RG Mike Pollak D-

C Jeff Saturday A- declining

LG Jamey Richard or Kyle DeVan (if re-signed) D-

LT Charlie Johnson (if re-signed) D+ Option is Jeff Linkenbach D-

RDE Dwight Freeney A

RDT Anthony Johnson C+ (if healthy)

LDT Fili Moala C+

LDE Robert Mathis B+

RLB Clint Session (if re-signed) or Kavell Conner C+ with potential

MLB Gary Brackett B- declining, but Angerer could step in

LLB Pat Angerer B- with potential

RCB Jerraud Powers B

LCB Kelvin Hayden B

3rd CB Justin Tryon B-

SS Melvin Bullitt (if re-signed) C+ Option is one of several D-

FS Antoine Bethea B+

K Adam Vinatieri (if re-signed) B declining Option is Brett Swenson D with potential

P Pat McAfee B+

LS Justin Snow B

KR Devin Moore C+ (if healthy)

PR Blair White C

Looks like they have a point